Jillian Green and her great aunt Cornelia win an auction for the contents of a storage unit. Mystery unfolds as they go through the unit. Some of the furnishings were for a family restaurant that closed years ago. The same time as owner Grace disappeared.

A new theater is opening in Moss Hollow and the woman in charge of its first production is caustic New York heiress Brittany Blaine who has set her sights on stealing both scenes and Jillian's handsome leading man, Hunter Greyson. But when Brittany is found dead at the bottom of the stage trapdoor, Jillian sets out to pull back the curtain on Brittany's suspicious demise.

Jillian Green gets roped in to instructing a teen baking class through the local parks department. Everyone participating in the class is full of enthusiasm except the program director, Louisa Byrne, a recent transplant to Moss Hollow who's failing to conceal her shaky nerves. When Louisa skips class unexpectedly, Jillian doesn't quite believe the woman's coworker when he claims she went to visit her sister. Did Louisa really ditch town for a family...