Two family vaults at the historic Colonial Park Cemetery have been broken in to, causing thousands of dollars of damage. Police dismiss the vandalism as a teenage prank, by chair of the cemetery board, Quin Crowley, does not agree. He hires Magnolia Investigations to look deeper into the incident. Meredith and Julia must sift through rumors and legends surrounding the cemetery to dig up the buried secrets each vault contains.

What happened to Eleanor? Through a miraculous turn of events, Debbie buys a fixer-upper craftsman-style home near the historic train depot. When she uncovers an old Victrola and a crate filled with WWII-era memorabilia, she pays a visit to Raymond, the longtime former homeowner. Among the items is a recording of a woman singing, Don't Sit Under the Apple Treey with a handwritten label that says To Ray, With Love, Eleanor. Seeing it brings tears...

Between 1887 and 1931, while living with her brother at a ighthouse on Elba Island, Florence Martus waved at every ship coming in and out of the port of Savannah. When author Regina Terrance releases a book claiming Florence was signaling enemy ships, Florence's great-great niece Mary hires Magnolia Investigations to clear her relative's name. Before Meredith and Julia can begin their investigation, the author goes missing and Mary is the chief suspect....